Mum shares her concerns for four year old daughter who keeps hurting their family dog.

The mum of three shared, “I want to know what I can do to help my 4-year-old daughter who constantly hurts our small dogs.

“She purposely hurts them when we aren’t in the room, or will go to them in a separate room and hit/kick/squeeze them. We catch her a lot, but only if we see it or the dogs make a noise.

“How many times has she done it when they haven’t yelped? I’m really worried she’s got some sort of psychological issue and enjoys hurting them? She gets in trouble and knows it’s wrong, she lies about hurting them too. What can I do to help?”

Internet responds

The major advice was for the mum to seek a professional opinion ASAP!

Jenny wrote, “That’s a sign of significant trauma in a child. Something has happened to her that has really scared her. She may not remember it. Hospitalisation, accident, birth or pregnancy? That needs to be treated by trauma informed practice…..”

Anna said, “Quite simply find a good child phsycologist. It may be nothing, but its better to address it now than later, and the phsycologist will be able to work with both you and your daughter. Do it as quickly as possible before something happens that make the dogs retaliate.”

Steph said, “Give the dog to a good home. Your daughter needs to see a psychiatrist.”

Megan was worried and shared, “Wtf! I’d be putting her in counselling that’s not normal and that’s how psychopath killers are made.”

Kathy agreed, “This child needs an immediate assessment.
Hurting animals CAN be an indicator of abuse, neglect, trauma and RAD – Reactive Attachment Disorder.”

Lisa shared, “I would definitely be seeking help. Neither of my children would ever hurt an animal. They respect our pets the same way they do people. And for the sake of the poor animals & the safety of your child, I would try to re-home your pets.”

While other parents felt it was just curiosity and she just needed to be taught how to treat animals kindly.

One mum said, “Don’t rush her to therapy just yet. Sometimes it’s a dominance thing. Do to her what she does to them and give no sympathy when she cries just tell her that’s how the dogs feel.”

Mary said, “Smack her back so she realises it isn’t nice. If she doesn’t like it tell her neither do the dogs. Take a her fave toy away when she hurts the dogs, give her time out for 5minutes, don’t allow her screen time..”

Kylie said, “I think it’s curiosities, I used to teach gently to my toddlers, if the kitty made a noice I would comfort the kitty and ignor the child after I told him he made her cry.”

Another said, “I would sit down and ask her why she is doing it. At 4 she should be able to explain to a certain extent why and how it makes her feel. You need to explain to her that if that kind of behaviour continues than the dogs can no longer stay. You know that she is like this so you need to make sure she is never left alone with animals for her protection and theirs.”

Jessie empathised adding, “She’s 4. 4 year olds don’t have empathy. When she does this pick up the dog and hug it and say things like “I know that hurt I’m sorry puppy, kiss the dogs owies and tell your daughter that one day puppy is going to get sick of it and bite her.””

Another agreed, “Don’t listen to these negative and awful comments that your child is a psychopath!! 4yo’s need guidance and love, they need to be taught what’s right and wrong using the right language. Instead of telling her she’s ‘naughty’ explain that the dog is part of your family and that we need to respect and love all creatures. You need to positively reinforce the times where she plays with the dog and doesn’t hurt them ie create games of tug a war, ball throwing etc. Teach her that dogs are beautiful and loving..”

What the experts say

An estimated 30 percent of children who witness domestic violence will perpetrate violence against animals, according to Psychology Today. Witnessing domestic violence is a scary experience for anyone, especially a child. A child may try to cope with feelings of insecurity and lack of control by hurting another animal to express their fears and anger.

However, animal cruelty can sometimes be the result of a child’s misunderstanding of an animal’s feelings and viewing an animal as a toy instead of a living thing. This is why it is important to consider a child’s animal cruelty behaviors in the context of their age.
Children ages 1-6: Children this age or a child who is developmentally delayed may not understand how to treat an animal or may see the animal as a toy. Just as parents must teach a child to play well with others, parents must also teach children to care for their animals.

Join our Facebook discussion below:


  • I was worried about my youngest years ago, but then read that kids don’t understand until 6. She’s now 6 and knows that animals feel pain and die etc.

    Reply


  • Maybe she should be made to realise how much what she is doing hurts – then a solid talking to before going down the medico path. She maybe thinks that the dog is being pampered more than herself.

    Reply


  • I’m thinking she might be jealous. In any case, it requires some real effort from parents to make her understand that dogs have feelings and how it would hurt. Perhaps give her some small responsibility with the dog and explain that he could become her best friend. I think a number of things before therapy… and the jump to psychopath perhaps a bit too soon!


    • I agree with some of the comments here – children are still little at this age and figuring things out. I think if the parents have changed a few things and it is still happening then they should talk to a professional about it.

    Reply


  • Maybe she’s just jealous, or an attention seeker and taking it out on the dogs, I would kennel the dogs for two weeks and see if she settles down.

    Reply


  • Maybe she has seen others do this to animals and think it’s what she’s meant to do. Try doing the same thing to her so she knows how much it hurts them. If that doesn’t work by all means talk to your GP and ask for their professional opinion. You need to stop it now before it escalates any further

    Reply


  • I think the child definitely needs to see a psychologist to determine any underlying issues.

    Reply


  • My son is 4 in a few months and he will sometimes hurt our animals for no reason but if we catch him we simply do to him whatever he did to the animal. He is getting an understanding and sometimes he’s actually quite affectionate to them too.

    Reply


  • That’s scary, they definitely need to seek professional help.

    Reply


  • Oh dear tough.situation…..yes it needs addressing SOON.

    Reply


  • Definitely should seek professional advice

    Reply


  • I wouldn’t be letting my child anywhere near the dog or vice versa. It’s only a matter of time before the dog snaps and bites her. for both their safety, they need to be kept separate.

    Reply


  • I think there is some sort of problem here beyond just learning how to treat an animal with kindness. She needs some professional help.

    Reply


  • oh I would be working on this quickly, the dog will only tolerate so much be it will react back and that could be very bad depending on the type and size of the dog.

    I hope that this mum and her daughter can work through the issues for theirs and the dogs sake

    Good luck to them

    Reply


  • Is it possible your daughter is jealous of the dog? e.g. She may think you should not be talking or giving any attention to the dog. Maybe if all else fails you should do to her very gently what she is doing to the dog. It may make her realise she is not being kind to the dog, that she is hurting it. You don’t have to hurt your daughter to do that, just put a little bit of physical grip on her. I know of examples which this method worked.

    Reply


  • Sounds like sensible advice from the expert to me. I can definitely understand the Mums concern though.

    Reply

Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?

No picture uploaded yet
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.

Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just submit?

Write A Rating Just Submit
Join